Treating flood risk at a regional distribution centre
A wholesale distributor decides how to treat flood risk at a centre that flooded once and now sits in a higher risk band than when it was acquired. The log works through the four standard treatments —...
The options
The question: How should flood risk at the regional distribution centre be treated: accept it with current arrangements, mitigate it with resilience works, transfer more of it through insurance, or avoid it by relocating the site?
Option 1: Accept: continue with current arrangements and absorb losses as they occur
For
- Rationale. Accepting costs nothing now and preserves every option for later, which has value while the revised mapping is still being contested by other occupiers in the same catchment.
Against
- Risk. It is not a stable position. The insurer has tied continued cover to evidence of resilience measures, so accepting the risk today most likely means being uninsured for it within two years, at which point the acceptance becomes involuntary.
- Risk. Fewer than half of orders were servable in 2023, and the independent retailers supplied from this centre have few alternative wholesalers. A repeat would put customer relationships at risk in a way the expected loss figure does not capture.
Option 2: Mitigate: install property flood resilience measures and raise critical operations above the design level
For
- Rationale. Mitigation is the only option that both reduces the loss and preserves the site, which matters because the lease runs to 2034 regardless of what the operation does.
- Official guidance. The Environment Agency's flood risk assessment standing advice sets out how flood risk is assessed for development, and is the planning context in which the revised mapping is read. The resilience works in the mitigation option are specified separately, against the CIRIA Code of practice for property flood resilience (C790), and it is against that code that their performance would be evidenced to the insurer.
Against
- Risk. The measures are specified against a design event derived from mapping that is itself an estimate and has already been revised once upward. Resilience works sized to a design level protect against that level and no further.
- Risk. Deployable barriers require someone to deploy them, with enough warning and enough people. The 2023 event gave eleven hours of notice overnight; the measures assume that is typical.
Option 3: Transfer: restructure the insurance programme with higher business interruption cover
For
- Rationale. Transfer is much the cheapest active treatment to implement and can be arranged inside one renewal cycle, where the resilience works would take two quarters to specify and install.
Against
- Risk. Transfer moves the financial consequence and leaves the operational one where it was. Nine days of lost despatch and 54 per cent of orders unservable are the same under this option as under doing nothing.
- Risk. A transfer strategy depends on a counterparty willing to accept the risk in future years. At a site under review for exactly that reason, the strategy is most likely to fail in the year it is most needed.
Option 4: Avoid: relocate the distribution centre outside the flood zone
For
- Rationale. Relocation is the only option that removes the exposure rather than reducing or financing it, and the only one whose result does not depend on a design level, a warning time or an insurer's appetite.
Against
- Risk. The lease runs to 2034 with no break. Unless an exit can be negotiated, the organisation pays for two sites for up to eight years, and the cost of the option is dominated by a figure it cannot establish without disclosing its intention to the landlord.
- Risk. Relocating one centre reopens the network design that was settled separately, because a new location changes the drive times to the other three and the volume each should carry.
Criteria and values
| Criterion | Option 1 | Option 2 | Option 3 | Option 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Expected annual loss | 410,000 GBP | 145,000 GBP | 180,000 GBP | 15,000 GBP |
| Continued insurability | doubtful | likely | doubtful | secure |
| Orders servable during the event | 46% | 78% | 46% | 100% |
| Outage in a design flood event | 9 day | 2 day | 9 day | 0 day |
| Residual risk | high | moderate | high | low |
| Time to take effect | 0 month | 6 month | 3 month | — |
| Upfront cost | 0 GBP | 1,850,000 GBP | 40,000 GBP | — |
What constrained the decision
- Constraint. The lease on the current site runs to 2034 with no break. Relocation therefore means carrying two property commitments or negotiating an exit, and the option is costed on the first of those because the second cannot be assumed.
- Constraint. The insurer has indicated that flood cover at this site will be renewed for one further year and reviewed thereafter against evidence of property flood resilience measures installed to the industry code of practice. Doing nothing is therefore not a stable position even if it is the cheapest today.
- Assumption. The catchment authority's revised flood mapping is a reasonable basis for the modelled event. It is more conservative than the mapping in force when the site was acquired, and the difference between the two is larger than the difference between several of the options below.
- Assumption. The other three distribution centres can absorb diverted volume at the rates assumed in the orders-servable figures. Two are within 10 per cent of their throughput ceiling at peak, so the assumption is weakest in exactly the season when a flood would be most likely.
Evidence
- Standard. The four treatment options considered here — accept, mitigate, transfer, avoid — correspond to the treatment options in ISO 31000 (avoiding the risk, changing its likelihood or consequence, sharing it, retaining it by informed decision), commonly summarised as avoid, mitigate, transfer and accept. The standard frames treatment as selecting among options and then implementing and monitoring them rather than as a single choice made once. The options below are therefore not mutually exclusive in principle, and the recommendation combines two of them.
- Research. Work on flood risk to commercial real estate reports that commercial building exposure is frequently understated because assessments focus on structural damage and omit the economic consequences of the building being unusable. The outage and orders-servable criteria below exist because of that finding: property damage alone would rank these options differently.