Stage gate decision on a major capital project business case
A public-sector infrastructure body's investment committee decides what to do with a capital business case at a stage gate: approve it, approve it with conditions, return it for rework, or reject it. ...
The options
The question: At the outline business case gate, should the investment committee approve the depot replacement project as submitted, approve it subject to conditions, return it for rework, or reject it and release the funding to the portfolio?
Option 1: Approve as submitted
For
- Benefit. Approving as submitted preserves the programme and the spring construction start, and the strategic case for replacing the depot was accepted at the previous gate and has not been challenged.
Against
- Risk. Approving on the strength of the strategic case when the management case is weak is the characteristic failure of gated approval. The five cases are separate for a reason, and a strong case for doing something is not evidence of the ability to do it.
- Risk. Reserving the full 47 million against a fixed envelope displaces three schemes on an estimate the independent reviewer would not put a range around. The displacement is certain and the cost it is being incurred for is not.
- Appraisal finding. The five cases in this submission are unevenly developed. The strategic case is strong and was accepted at the previous gate. The economic case is adequate. The management case is the weakest of the five: the delivery organisation is described as an intention rather than evidenced, and no project director has been appointed.
- Assurance finding. The independent cost review records that 38 per cent of the design is fixed at this stage, against the 60 per cent the organisation's own assurance standard expects at outline business case. The estimate is described as indicative, and the reviewer declined to give a confidence range on it.
Option 2: Approve subject to conditions, with the next tranche released only when the conditions are met
For
- Benefit. Conditions attach the committee's concerns to a verifiable event rather than to a hope: a project director appointed and design maturity at the standard, both testable before the next tranche.
Against
- Risk. Conditional approval reserves the full 47 million against the envelope while releasing little cash, so it displaces three schemes for a project that may still not proceed. It is the option that most resembles having decided without having decided.
- Risk. Conditions are frequently reported as met on the papers rather than in substance, and the committee that set them is rarely the body that verifies them. Without a named verifier this option decays into unconditional approval with a delay.
Option 3: Return the case for rework and re-submission at the next gate
For
- Benefit. Returning the case is the response the gated model contemplates for a case whose five dimensions are unevenly developed: the deficiency is in the submission rather than in the proposal, and returning it addresses the deficiency directly.
- Benefit. Returning the case keeps the proposal alive without reserving anything against the envelope, so the three competing schemes are not displaced by a proposal that has not yet demonstrated it can be delivered.
- Recommendation. Return the case for rework and re-submission at the next gate, with the rework scoped to the management case and design maturity. It is the only option that neither commits the envelope against an estimate the independent reviewer would not put a range around, nor rejects a proposal whose strategic case the committee itself accepted. Conditional approval was considered and is not recommended: it reserves the full 47 million against the envelope while deciding nothing, which is the appearance of caution rather than caution.
Against
- Risk. The existing depot lease expires in 31 months. A rework that loses the construction season puts the replacement beyond that date and creates a cost for interim accommodation that has not been established and is in no option's figures.
Option 4: Reject and release the funding to the competing schemes
For
- Benefit. Rejection releases the envelope to schemes whose cases are complete, which serves the portfolio prioritisation the committee is responsible for.
Against
- Risk. The strategic case for depot replacement was accepted at the previous gate and has not been withdrawn. Rejecting the submission rejects a proposal for its documentation rather than for its merits, and the need it addresses does not go away.
- Risk. The lease expiry becomes certain rather than at risk. Rejection makes interim accommodation a near certainty and its cost is still not established.
Criteria and values
| Criterion | Option 1 | Option 2 | Option 3 | Option 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Spend committed by the decision | 6,200,000 GBP | 2,400,000 GBP | 400,000 GBP | 0 GBP |
| Confidence in the cost estimate | low | low | moderate | — |
| Delivery capability evidenced | weak | adequate | adequate | — |
| Risk of needing interim accommodation | low | low | moderate | high |
| Portfolio displacement | 47,000,000 GBP | 47,000,000 GBP | 0 GBP | 0 GBP |
| Ability to stop at the next gate | low | moderate | high | — |
| Delay to first operation | 0 month | 2 month | — | 24 month |
What constrained the decision
- Constraint. The capital envelope for the five-year programme is fixed. Approving this proposal at the submitted value displaces other schemes; there is no option in which the money is found elsewhere.
- Constraint. The lease on the existing depot expires in 31 months. A replacement not operational by then requires interim accommodation, the cost of which is not in any option below because it has not been established.
- Assumption. The three schemes displaced by this approval would each deliver returns comparable to those they were appraised at. Two were appraised more than eighteen months ago and neither has been re-tested against current construction cost inflation.
- Assumption. A return for rework can be completed and re-submitted at the following gate without losing a construction season. The programme assumes a spring start; a re-submission that slips past that point costs a year rather than a quarter.
Evidence
- Framework. The business case follows the five case model recommended by HM Treasury's Green Book: strategic, economic, commercial, financial and management cases. The model treats a business case as iterative across three stages corresponding to the approval stages, with detail added to each of the five dimensions at each stage. The committee's task at this gate is therefore whether the five cases are sufficiently developed for this stage, not whether the project is a good idea.
- Appraisal finding. The five cases in this submission are unevenly developed. The strategic case is strong and was accepted at the previous gate. The economic case is adequate. The management case is the weakest of the five: the delivery organisation is described as an intention rather than evidenced, and no project director has been appointed.
Related decisions
- How a metropolitan police service should reorganise its public-order capability after criticism of protest tactics
- How a national government should respond to a court ruling that limits its major-project permitting law
- Applying an unexpected revenue windfall in an annual budget: deficit reduction, household relief, investment incentives or a staged reserve
- How a large metropolitan government should structure its response to recurring seasonal air-quality episodes
- Responding to a diesel supply crisis with a coordinated emergency stock release