Made by AI, reviewed by Ivan Jureta on .
Illustrative scenario. This log describes a hypothetical decision; organisations are identified by role, not by name.
How a national government should respond to a court ruling that limits its major-project permitting law
A national government must respond after a court rules that parts of its permitting law for major projects reach into matters for regional governments. The log compares seeking review by the highest court, amending the law, doing both in parallel, and replacing the regime with a co-operative framework with regional governments. Readers can see how time to legal certainty, residual constitutional risk, retained national oversight, investor certainty, legislative effort and stakeholder positions trade off, and how the proposed amendment route is governed, implemented and kept under review.
The options
The question: How should a national government respond to a court ruling that parts of its major-project permitting law reach into matters for regional governments: seek review by the highest court, amend the law, amend and seek review in parallel, or replace the regime with a co-operative framework?
Option 1: Seek review by the highest court
For
- Contemporaneous public reporting indicated that environmental lawyers urged further review by the highest court, arguing that the national government should defend its authority over the review of major projects rather than concede it.
Against
- Seeking review keeps the regime's reach unsettled for the life of the proceedings, and an adverse ruling from the highest court would leave the government with less room to legislate than it has now.
- Amending the law is the proposed course because it answers the defects the ruling identified, keeps national review where national authority is clear, and gives proponents a settled rule sooner than litigation would. Seeking review by the highest court is not preferred because it defends features the court has criticised and prolongs uncertainty. Amending and seeking review in parallel is not preferred because the review would argue for a regime the government is changing, and the litigation would keep uncertainty alive. Replacing the regime with a new co-operative framework is not preferred now because it would take longest to negotiate and enact and depends on agreements with regional governments that are not in place.
- Research by Baker, Bloom and Davis finds that rises in economic policy uncertainty are followed by lower investment and hiring, with the strongest firm-level effects in policy-sensitive sectors such as infrastructure construction.
Option 2: Amend the law
For
- The ruling accepted that a national permitting regime is permissible within national authority; its objection was the breadth of discretion over regional matters, which targeted amendments can address directly.
- Further amendment can build on the government's existing power to adjust the schedule of project types that trigger national permitting, so part of the narrowing can take effect quickly.
- Amending the law is the proposed course because it answers the defects the ruling identified, keeps national review where national authority is clear, and gives proponents a settled rule sooner than litigation would. Seeking review by the highest court is not preferred because it defends features the court has criticised and prolongs uncertainty. Amending and seeking review in parallel is not preferred because the review would argue for a regime the government is changing, and the litigation would keep uncertainty alive. Replacing the regime with a new co-operative framework is not preferred now because it would take longest to negotiate and enact and depends on agreements with regional governments that are not in place.
- The national environment minister takes this decision with the cabinet, on the advice of the justice ministry's constitutional lawyers and the national permitting agency.
- Regional governments, Indigenous rights holders, project proponents and environmental organisations are to be consulted on the content of the amendments and on interim arrangements before legislation is tabled.
Against
- A second round of amendments may again be challenged, narrows the national role in projects that are mainly regional, and is opposed by groups that favour strong national review; its interaction with the separate work to speed up reviews is not yet clear.
Option 3: Amend and seek review in parallel
For
- Amending while seeking review hedges the government's position: if the highest court narrowed the ruling, the amendments could be calibrated to the narrower reading.
- The ruling accepted that a national permitting regime is permissible within national authority; its objection was the breadth of discretion over regional matters, which targeted amendments can address directly.
Against
- Seeking review while amending asks the highest court to rule on a text that is being replaced, which risks the review being treated as moot and sends mixed signals to proponents and regional governments.
- Seeking review keeps the regime's reach unsettled for the life of the proceedings, and an adverse ruling from the highest court would leave the government with less room to legislate than it has now.
- Amending the law is the proposed course because it answers the defects the ruling identified, keeps national review where national authority is clear, and gives proponents a settled rule sooner than litigation would. Seeking review by the highest court is not preferred because it defends features the court has criticised and prolongs uncertainty. Amending and seeking review in parallel is not preferred because the review would argue for a regime the government is changing, and the litigation would keep uncertainty alive. Replacing the regime with a new co-operative framework is not preferred now because it would take longest to negotiate and enact and depends on agreements with regional governments that are not in place.
Option 4: Replace with a co-operative framework
For
- A co-operative framework built on one review per project, with national conditions limited to clearly national matters, would remove most duplication and most of the jurisdictional dispute at its source.
- The same OECD Recommendation asks governments to promote regulatory coherence through co-ordination between national and regional levels of government, to avoid duplication or conflict of regulations.
Against
- A new framework would take longest to negotiate and enact, may produce uneven standards across regional jurisdictions, and leaves the existing regime in legal doubt in the meantime.
- Amending the law is the proposed course because it answers the defects the ruling identified, keeps national review where national authority is clear, and gives proponents a settled rule sooner than litigation would. Seeking review by the highest court is not preferred because it defends features the court has criticised and prolongs uncertainty. Amending and seeking review in parallel is not preferred because the review would argue for a regime the government is changing, and the litigation would keep uncertainty alive. Replacing the regime with a new co-operative framework is not preferred now because it would take longest to negotiate and enact and depends on agreements with regional governments that are not in place.
Criteria and values
| Criterion | Option 1 | Option 2 | Option 3 | Option 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Environmental advocate acceptance | high | low | — | low |
| Intergovernmental conflict | high | moderate | high | low |
| Legislative and administrative effort | low | moderate | high | high |
| Near-term investor certainty | low | moderate | low | low |
| Residual constitutional risk | high | moderate | moderate | low |
| Retained national oversight | high | moderate | moderate | low |
| Time to legal certainty | 24 month | 12 month | 24 month | — |
Evidence
Sources
Related decisions
- How a metropolitan police service should reorganise its public-order capability after criticism of protest tactics
- Applying an unexpected revenue windfall in an annual budget: deficit reduction, household relief, investment incentives or a staged reserve
- How a large metropolitan government should structure its response to recurring seasonal air-quality episodes
- Responding to a diesel supply crisis with a coordinated emergency stock release
- Why Choose Three Single-Tier Councils?