Rollout approach for autonomous haulage at an open-pit operation
An open-pit mine decides how to introduce autonomous haul trucks: a mixed-fleet pilot, conversion pit by pit, a single fleet-wide campaign, or full conversion of one pit with operation segregated rath...
The options
The question: How should autonomous haulage be introduced at the operation: a small pilot in one pit, conversion pit by pit, conversion of the whole fleet in a single campaign, or full conversion of one pit with no mixed operation anywhere?
Option 1: Pilot six trucks in one pit alongside the manned fleet
For
- Rationale. The pilot tests the technology against this operation's own haul profile, which is the assumption most likely to be wrong in the published figures.
Against
- Risk. A pilot maximises the very state the guideline requires to be explicitly controlled: a small autonomous fleet mixed with a large manned one, for a long period, with the interaction control exercised constantly. It buys information about throughput at the cost of sustained exposure to the interaction hazard.
- Risk. The throughput result from a mixed pit will not answer the question the pilot was run to answer, because the autonomous trucks are constrained by the manned traffic around them. The pilot can demonstrate that the system works; it cannot demonstrate what it is worth.
Option 2: Convert pit by pit over three years, trucks converted progressively within each pit alongside manned trucks
For
- Rationale. Under phased conversion, lessons from the first pit inform the second and third, and capital is released in tranches against demonstrated results rather than all at once.
Against
- Risk. Thirty months of mixed operation is the longest exposure of any option to the hazard the guideline requires to be explicitly controlled. Phasing reduces commercial risk by increasing the duration of a safety risk, and the two are not in the same currency.
- Risk. A three-year conversion assumes the mine plan holds for three years. Two pits have sequences that would be costly to alter once conversion has started in them.
Option 3: Convert the whole fleet in a single campaign
For
- Rationale. A single campaign minimises the period of mixed operation, the state the industry guideline requires to be explicitly controlled, and reaches the benefit soonest.
Against
- Risk. It commits the whole capital against figures no one has reproduced on this haul profile. If the gain lands at the bottom of the range or below it, the operation has converted a fleet it cannot un-convert on a business case that did not hold.
- Risk. One hundred and twenty-eight operator roles change in a single step, against an enterprise agreement requiring consultation and an offer of retraining. Concentrating that into one change is the workforce transition the research identifies as where implementations most often fail.
- Industry evidence. Reported results from operations that have converted include throughput increases of the order of 15 to 20 per cent and unit cost reductions of around 15 per cent, with some operators reporting higher figures. These are operator-reported results from specific sites rather than controlled comparisons, and the operations reporting them differ from this one in ore body, haul profile and fleet age. No controlled study is cited for the range; it is used here only as a starting assumption to be tested.
Option 4: Convert one pit fully, with autonomous and manned operation segregated by pit rather than mixed on shared roads
For
- Rationale. Segregating by pit removes the interaction hazard between changeover windows rather than controlling it throughout. The guideline's treatment of mixed operation as a state requiring explicit control is best satisfied by an arrangement that does not enter that state at all.
- Rationale. A fully converted pit produces a throughput figure for this operation's own haul profile, unpaced by manned traffic, which is the number every other option assumes at the point it commits most of its capital.
- Risk. Thirty months of mixed operation is the longest exposure of any option to the hazard the guideline requires to be explicitly controlled. Phasing reduces commercial risk by increasing the duration of a safety risk, and the two are not in the same currency.
- Recommendation. Convert one pit fully, segregated from manned operation, then extend pit by pit on the measured result. It produces a throughput figure measured on this operation's own haul profile before most of the capital is committed, which no other option does, while committing about 30 per cent of the capital the single campaign requires. It spends about six months in mixed operation, in three two-month changeover windows, against thirty for the phased option; that is two months more than the single campaign, accepted in exchange for the measurement and consultation rounds a third the size. Segregation removes the hazard between windows where phasing controls it for longer, at the cost of inter-pit fleet flexibility, which the review triggers watch.
Against
- Risk. Segregation constrains the mine plan: trucks cannot be moved between pits to meet a schedule change, so flexibility the operation currently relies on is lost for the duration.
- Risk. It requires the first pit to be one where full conversion is practical, which is not necessarily the pit where the business case is strongest. The option may prove the technology on the least representative ground available.
Criteria and values
| Criterion | Option 1 | Option 2 | Option 3 | Option 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Capital committed before proof | 14,000,000 USD | 31,000,000 USD | 96,000,000 USD | 29,000,000 USD |
| Inter-pit fleet flexibility | moderate | moderate | high | low |
| Months of mixed-fleet operation | 18 month | 30 month | 4 month | 6 month |
| Ability to stop or reverse | high | moderate | low | moderate |
| Operator roles changed in one step | 18 | 44 | 128 | 44 |
| Steady-state throughput gain | 3% | 15% | 15% | 15% |
| Time to full benefit | — | 36 month | 10 month | 30 month |
What constrained the decision
- Constraint. Any period in which autonomous and manned trucks share haul roads requires a documented interaction control and a revised traffic management plan approved before operation. Mixed operation is permitted but is a controlled state rather than a transitional convenience.
- Constraint. The operation has an enterprise agreement obligation to consult on changes affecting operator roles, and to offer retraining before redeployment. No option may commence conversion before that consultation has concluded.
- Assumption. The published throughput gains are attainable here at the lower end of the reported range. The haul profile at this operation is steeper than at the operations reporting the highest figures, and no adjustment for that has been calculated.
- Assumption. Mine plan stability over the conversion period. Two of the three pits have a planned sequence that would be difficult to alter once conversion has begun in them, and a change to the plan mid-conversion would strand equipment configured for a specific pit.
- Assumption. Each pit can be given its own haul route and tipping point at the crusher and waste dumps, so that a converted pit's trucks never share road with another pit's manned trucks. Where that is not possible, segregation weakens to a controlled interface at the point where the routes converge.
Evidence
- Research. Published work on implementing autonomous haulage trucks reports safety benefits arising from reduced human exposure to the haulage environment and from removing fatigue and operator error as accident mechanisms, alongside management challenges in workforce transition and in the new hazards the systems introduce. Both halves of that finding are represented in the options below.
- Industry evidence. Reported results from operations that have converted include throughput increases of the order of 15 to 20 per cent and unit cost reductions of around 15 per cent, with some operators reporting higher figures. These are operator-reported results from specific sites rather than controlled comparisons, and the operations reporting them differ from this one in ore body, haul profile and fleet age. No controlled study is cited for the range; it is used here only as a starting assumption to be tested.