Adopting a mechanism for allocating critical care capacity during a surge
A four-site hospital group decides, in ordinary conditions and in advance, what mechanism would allocate critical care capacity if demand exceeded it. The log is about the mechanism rather than the cl...
The options
The question: What mechanism should allocate critical care capacity if demand exceeds it during a surge: bedside clinical judgement as now, published criteria applied by the treating clinician, a separate triage team at each site, or a single team across the group?
Option 1: Retain bedside clinical judgement with no standing mechanism
For
- Benefit. Retaining bedside judgement requires nothing to be built, trained or maintained, and it is what the group does today.
Against
- Risk. It cannot satisfy the constraint of consistent and impartial application, because there is nothing to apply consistently. Decisions of this gravity would be made without a framework, without a record designed for review, and differently at each site.
- Risk. Not choosing a mechanism is itself a choice, made by default and taken under the worst possible conditions when the surge arrives. The published guidance is directed precisely at avoiding that.
- Risk. Allocation arrangements may be challenged as discriminatory, as several published model policies were in 2020 and revised afterwards. Arrangements adopted in advance by the governing body, with a recorded rationale, published criteria and an independent appeal, are easier to examine and defend than decisions made case by case without a record.
Option 2: Publish criteria and an activation threshold, applied by the treating clinician
For
- Benefit. Publishing criteria and a threshold is materially better than the status quo on consistency and on activation clarity, and it can be implemented without any new rota.
Against
- Risk. It leaves the treating clinician deciding access for their own patient, which the published model policy specifically separates. The separation exists both to secure consistency and to protect the clinician, and this option delivers the first only in part and the second not at all.
- Risk. A clinician applying allocation criteria to a patient they are treating faces a conflict between two duties they hold simultaneously. Published guidance treats the duty to care as continuing regardless, which is precisely why the allocation judgement is placed elsewhere.
- Model policy. Published model policy on the allocation of scarce critical care resources during a public health emergency provides that triage decisions are not made by the patient's treating clinicians, but by a designated triage team, in order to secure consistency and to separate the person deciding access from the person providing care.
- Risk. Allocation arrangements may be challenged as discriminatory, as several published model policies were in 2020 and revised afterwards. Arrangements adopted in advance by the governing body, with a recorded rationale, published criteria and an independent appeal, are easier to examine and defend than decisions made case by case without a record.
Option 3: Standing policy with a designated triage team at each site
For
- Benefit. A triage team at each site is the arrangement the published frameworks describe, so the group would be adopting a documented approach rather than devising one, and could point to that provenance if the mechanism were ever examined.
- Model policy. Published model policy on the allocation of scarce critical care resources during a public health emergency provides that triage decisions are not made by the patient's treating clinicians, but by a designated triage team, in order to secure consistency and to separate the person deciding access from the person providing care.
Against
- Risk. Twenty-four trained staff must be maintained against an event that may not occur for years. Training decays, staff move, and a mechanism that is documented but not rehearsed performs like one that was never written.
- Risk. Four separate teams may diverge in how they apply common criteria, particularly if they train separately. The option secures consistency within a site more reliably than across the group.
Option 4: Standing policy with a single triage team across the group, with capacity balanced between sites
For
- Benefit. A single team also allows capacity to be balanced across sites, so that a patient is allocated against the group's capacity rather than the capacity of the hospital they happened to reach.
- Risk. Four separate teams may diverge in how they apply common criteria, particularly if they train separately. The option secures consistency within a site more reliably than across the group.
Against
- Risk. A single team is a single point of failure and a potential queue. If referral volume during a surge exceeds what one team can consider promptly, the mechanism becomes the delay, and the time to allocation is unconfirmed for exactly that reason.
- Risk. Balancing capacity between sites entails transferring patients, which carries its own clinical risk and is not always possible for the sickest. The benefit is smaller in practice than the arrangement suggests.
Criteria and values
| Criterion | Option 1 | Option 2 | Option 3 | Option 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Clarity of the activation threshold | unclear | defined | defined | defined |
| Consistency across patients and sites | low | moderate | high | high |
| Reassessment and appeal provision | none | partial | full | full |
| Trained staff required to operate | 0 | 0 | 24 | 12 |
| Time to an allocation decision | 1 hour | 2 hour | 4 hour | — |
| Burden on the treating clinician | high | moderate | low | low |
What constrained the decision
- Constraint. Any mechanism must be capable of consistent, impartial and non-discriminatory application, and must be documented before it is needed. A mechanism designed during a surge cannot demonstrate that it was designed impartially.
- Constraint. The mechanism must not be capable of activation on the judgement of a single clinician or a single site. The model policy this log follows requires both exhausted surge capacity and a declaration by an appropriate authority.
- Assumption. A surge sufficient to exhaust conventional capacity is possible but not probable in any given year. Every option is therefore assessed on the staff it must keep trained and ready as well as on how it performs when used, because it will spend most of its life not being used.
- Assumption. Staff trained for a triage role remain available to perform it during a surge. This is the least secure assumption in the decision: a surge that exhausts critical care capacity is also a surge that places demands on senior clinicians elsewhere.
Evidence
- Ethical guidance. Published guidance on the ethical allocation of scarce resources grounds such frameworks in the duty to care, the duty to steward resources, distributive and procedural justice, and transparency, and requires decision-making that is consistent, impartial, neutral and non-discriminatory. Procedural justice is the reason the mechanism, and not only the criteria, is the subject of this decision.
- Research. Published work on frameworks for critical care triage during a major surge in critical illness describes reassessment of allocations already made as a component of the framework rather than an addition to it, since an allocation made at one point in a surge may not remain appropriate as circumstances change.