prorso Guide Library Articles Features Enterprise
For teams
Sign inCreate account

Board decision on a head office lease break

Open in the app

By · Published

A United Kingdom board decides whether to renew, relocate, release or sublet its head office at a lease break with a hard notice date. The log shows measured occupancy used as a decision criterion, th...

The options

The question: The head office lease contains a break in September 2027. Should the board renew the existing lease, relocate to smaller premises, release the space entirely, or renew and sublet the unused floors?

Option 1: Renew the existing lease for a further five years

For

  • Agent advice. The landlord's terms of 2 July 2026 propose a five-year renewal at a rent uplift of 4 per cent and no break, which the retained agent advised is below the level expected for comparable space in the area.

Against

  • Risk. Renewal commits approximately 3.9 million pounds of rent, service charge and rates over five years for space measured at 2.82 desks per daily attendee, with no break clause through which the decision could be corrected if attendance falls further.
  • Risk. It places the largest lease liability of the four options, shared with subletting, on the balance sheet at the point the enterprise system replacement is also drawing on capital.

Option 2: Relocate to smaller premises within the same city

For

  • Market evidence. Three buildings were shortlisted at 110 desks, averaging 430,000 pounds a year for rent, service charge and rates. Against renewal at 780,000 pounds, the annual saving of 350,000 pounds pays back the one-off cost of 620,000 pounds in approximately 21 months, or in about 11 months if the dilapidations, which renewal defers rather than avoids, are left out.
  • Rationale. The option retains a physical workplace for apprentices, graduates and staff who prefer to attend, which the survey indicated a majority value, while removing space that measurement shows is not used.
  • Recommendation. That the board resolve to serve break notice and relocate to smaller premises within the city, subject to the condition precedent set out below. Renewal is not recommended: it commits approximately 3.9 million pounds of rent, service charge and rates over five years and the largest balance sheet liability of the four options, shared with subletting, for space measured at 2.82 desks per daily attendee, with no break through which the commitment could be corrected. Serving notice preserves both relocation and release. Release is not carried forward because the training arrangements for apprentices and graduates assume a workplace and a majority of survey respondents value one, which makes it unlikely to survive consultation; it has not been consulted on, and its cost case is not the reason. The board may instead direct a consultation on release before a building is contracted. Subletting is not recommended because it carries the full commitment and liability of renewal while making the cost outcome depend on a letting market the organisation cannot influence.

Against

  • Risk. The one-off cost of approximately 620,000 pounds falls in a single financial year in which the enterprise system replacement is also drawing on capital. The combined effect on covenant headroom has not been tested.
  • Risk. Fourteen employees report that the move would materially worsen their commute, concentrated in a team that attends more often than average. Building selection could mitigate this but cannot remove it.

Option 3: Release the space entirely and operate without a head office

For

  • Estimate. Meeting-space hire at current market rates on the last two quarters' booking pattern, plus a registered office service, gives approximately 95,000 pounds a year. The figure moves with how often teams choose to meet, and the organisation would carry no lease liability and no commitment of any length.

Against

  • Risk. An average of 78 people attend by choice each day. Removing the workplace entirely is a larger change to their working conditions than any other option, and the consultation did not test it. Proceeding without asking would leave the section 172 assessment incomplete on the option with the greatest employee effect.
  • Risk. Apprentices and graduate entrants have no supervised setting. The training arrangements the organisation has entered into assume a workplace, and the alternative has not been designed.

Option 4: Renew and sublet the two unused floors

For

  • Lease terms. The lease permits the subletting of whole floors with the landlord's consent, which the retained agent advised would be likely to be granted.

Against

  • Risk. The sublet income is an agent's estimate against a market with vacancy at 14 per cent and no identified tenant. If the floors remain empty the option is renewal with a further 85,000 pounds spent, which is the worst outcome available from this decision.
  • Risk. It carries the full commitment and full balance sheet liability of renewal while making the cost outcome dependent on a letting market the organisation does not operate in and cannot influence.

Criteria and values

CriterionOption 1Option 2Option 3Option 4
Annual property cost (lower is better)780,000 GBP430,000 GBP95,000 GBP—
Length of commitment (lower is better)5 year3 year0 year5 year
Desks per daily attendee2.821.41—1.54
Lease liability recognised (lower is better)2,690,000 GBP940,000 GBP0 GBP2,690,000 GBP
One-off cost (lower is better)0 GBP620,000 GBP380,000 GBP85,000 GBP
Staff materially affected (lower is better)014—0

What constrained the decision

Evidence

Related decisions

Open the decision log in the app

Spotted an error? Report a problem (ivan@ivanjureta.com). Corrections are listed on the page with their date.