Allocating a reduced irrigation licence across a growing season
An arable farming enterprise whose abstraction licence has been cut by 30 per cent decides how to spread the remaining water across four crops. The log shows why a proportional cut is the most expensi...
The options
The question: The abstraction licence has been reduced by 30 per cent for the coming season. How should the available water be allocated across the cropped area?
Option 1: Apply the reduction pro rata: irrigate every crop at 70 per cent of its normal schedule
For
- Advantage. The option requires no new capability, no new equipment and no change to the irrigation calendar. It can be implemented by the existing team in the week the decision is taken.
Against
- Risk. A uniform deficit ignores the central finding of the yield response framework: withholding water during a sensitive growth stage can cost several times the yield of withholding the same volume during an insensitive one. This option withholds indiscriminately and therefore buys the least yield for the water it saves.
Option 2: Concentrate: irrigate the contracted crops fully and leave wheat and sunflower unirrigated
For
- Advantage. It removes contract compensation from the outcome entirely, which is the one financial consequence in this decision with a defined counterparty rather than an estimate.
Against
- Risk. It treats the two uncontracted crops as having no value beyond their margin. Rainfed wheat on land that is normally irrigated is the crop most exposed to a dry season, and a failed wheat crop weakens the soil condition from which the next crop in the rotation starts.
- Risk. Full irrigation of the contracted crops leaves only about four per cent of the licence in hand. A hot spell in late season would find too little water to respond with, on the crops that carry the contracts.
Option 3: Schedule the deficit by growth stage: irrigate every crop, withholding water at the stages where each is least sensitive
For
- Research. Deficit irrigation is documented for sugar beet, sunflower and wheat; potato is more sensitive, so the schedule withholds little from it after tuber initiation. The option applies the practice where the literature supports it and protects the crop where it does not.
- Risk. A uniform deficit ignores the central finding of the yield response framework: withholding water during a sensitive growth stage can cost several times the yield of withholding the same volume during an insensitive one. This option withholds indiscriminately and therefore buys the least yield for the water it saves.
- Guidance. FAO material on deficit irrigation scheduling by plant growth stage sets out that crops have stages at which water stress costs little yield and stages at which it costs a great deal, and that scheduling a deficit into the insensitive stages is what distinguishes a managed deficit from simple under-irrigation.
- Guidance. FAO material on deficit irrigation practices reports that deficit irrigation has been applied to field crops including sugar beet, sunflower and wheat with small yield losses relative to the water saved, and that the gain in water productivity depends on keeping the deficit out of the sensitive stages. Crops with a yield response factor above 1, such as potato, tolerate it less well.
- Recommendation. Schedule the deficit by growth stage, conditional on the monitoring capacity being secured before planting. It returns the highest forecast margin and keeps all land in production, and it does so by placing the same reduced volume of water where the published yield response framework says it earns most. It is preferred to concentrating on the contracted crops because it gives up a small, tolerated sugar beet shortfall for about 53,000 euros of additional margin.
Against
- Risk. Thirty-four additional labour days, about a day and a half a week through the irrigation season, is not in the labour budget, and part of it falls in the weeks of harvest preparation. If the monitoring is not done the option degrades to a stage deficit timed by calendar rather than measurement, and much of its margin advantage is at risk.
- Risk. The yield response coefficients are published values, not local ones. If this holding's soils hold water differently from those the coefficients were derived on, the stage boundaries move and the deficit lands in the wrong week.
- Guidance. FAO material on irrigation scheduling under limited water notes that the practice depends on knowing soil moisture through the season rather than applying a fixed calendar, and that this is a principal operational constraint on adopting it.
Option 4: Reduce the irrigated area: take 30 per cent of the irrigated land out of production and irrigate the rest fully
For
- Advantage. It is the only option whose outcome is largely insensitive to how the season turns out, because everything that is grown is fully watered.
Against
- Risk. Fixed costs continue on land that produces nothing, and the rotation is displaced for two further seasons. It is the only option whose consequences outlast the season it was taken for.
Criteria and values
| Criterion | Option 1 | Option 2 | Option 3 | Option 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Contracted tonnage deliverable | 84% | 100% | 96% | 88% |
| Forecast gross margin | 612,000 EUR | 688,000 EUR | 741,000 EUR | 655,000 EUR |
| Effect on the rotation | none | limited | none | material |
| Scheduling and monitoring demand | 2 day | 0 day | 34 day | 0 day |
| Share of reduced licence used | 99% | 96% | 97% | 94% |
| Downside yield risk | high | moderate | moderate | low |
What constrained the decision
- Constraint. The licence reduction is fixed for the season and cannot be appealed within the planting window. Unused entitlement does not carry forward to the following year.
- Constraint. The potato and sugar beet contracts carry tonnage commitments with compensation payable on any shortfall beyond a tolerance stated in each contract. The contracts were signed before the licence reduction was notified and cannot be varied unilaterally.
- Assumption. Seasonal rainfall falls within the range of the last ten years. Every option is built on that range; a season below it changes the ranking, which is why downside yield risk is a criterion rather than a note.
- Assumption. Yield response coefficients are taken from the published framework for these crops and have not been calibrated on this holding's own soils. Local calibration would change the numbers; it is unlikely to change which stages are sensitive, which is what the recommended option turns on.
Evidence
- Guidance. FAO Irrigation and Drainage Paper 66, Crop yield response to water, provides the yield response framework used here. Its central point for this decision is that yield loss scales with the crop's evapotranspiration deficit through a yield response factor, Ky, and that Ky differs by growth stage: the same deficit costs more yield at flowering or yield formation than during vegetative growth or ripening.
- Guidance. FAO material on irrigation scheduling under limited water notes that the practice depends on knowing soil moisture through the season rather than applying a fixed calendar, and that this is a principal operational constraint on adopting it.