Not Appealing: When Accepting an Adverse Ruling Is a Decision
When a court or tribunal finds against a decision, the authority that made it chooses whether to contest the finding, accept it and rebuild, or wait. This text treats that choice as a decision in its own right, describes the criteria and mechanisms that shape it, and sets out what governing it costs.
- A decision not to contest an adverse ruling is a decision, with its own criteria, decision rights, and consequences. It is distinct from abandoning the goal the original decision served. - The choice usually has at least four options: appeal, accept and redesign, accept and do nothing yet, or seek a narrower clarification. Treating it as appeal or not appeal hides the alternatives. - The people who made the original decision have the strongest incentive to defend it. Escalation of commitment is the main mechanism that biases this choice toward contesting. - Accepting a ruling opens an interval in which the old rule is in doubt and the new one does not yet exist. That interval needs its own rules. - The reasons for not contesting are part of the record. Without them, others read the choice as concession, weakness, or strategy, depending on their interests. - Governing the choice costs time and can reduce flexibility. It also makes the authority's next contested decision more predictable to the parties who depend on it.
**1. The case that raises the question**
On 12 November 2026, the office of Canada's Environment Minister, Julie Dabrusin, told The Canadian Press that the federal government would not appeal an Alberta Court of Appeal opinion finding parts of the amended *Impact Assessment Act* unconstitutional, and would instead amend the Act ([Murray, 2026](https://www.ckom.com/2026/11/12/feds-wont-appeal-alberta-court-ruling-that-impact-assessment-act-is-unconstitutional/)). Press secretary Amy Falkner said Canada would "move quickly to provide certainty to investors, industry and Indigenous Peoples" and that the details of the amendments "will be confirmed in due course." In the meantime, the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada would continue to work with project proponents on their assessments. The amendments are to be coordinated with Bill C-39, which is before Parliament and would move some project reviews to other federal regulators.
The ruling was the second judicial finding against the Act. In 2023, the Supreme Court of Canada found much of the original Act beyond federal jurisdiction (*Reference re Impact Assessment Act*, 2023). Parliament amended the Act in 2024. On 9 October 2026, in a reference brought by Alberta, a majority of the Alberta Court of Appeal found that the amended scheme still reached too far into provincial jurisdiction, with one judge dissenting ([Blakes, 2026](https://www.blakes.com/insights/alberta-court-of-appeal-finds-impact-assessment-act-is-unconstitutional-again/)). The court wrote that the Act "creates great uncertainty due to the potential for previously unpronounced standards to apply to designated projects" ([Murray, 2026](https://www.ckom.com/2026/11/12/feds-wont-appeal-alberta-court-ruling-that-impact-assessment-act-is-unconstitutional/)). Because the ruling is an advisory opinion on a reference, the Act remains in force until it is changed ([Blakes, 2026](https://www.blakes.com/insights/alberta-court-of-appeal-finds-impact-assessment-act-is-unconstitutional-again/)).
Reactions divided along predictable lines. Alberta's premier had urged Ottawa not to appeal. Environmental law organizations called the choice disappointing and said it created uncertainty about federal assessment ([The Energy Mix, 2026](https://www.theenergymix.com/feds-wont-appeal-alberta-court-ruling-that-impact-assessment-act-is-unconstitutional/); [Ecojustice, 2026](https://ecojustice.ca/news/federal-governments-decision-not-to-appeal-the-impact-assessment-ruling-creates-uncertainty-for-environmental-protection/)). The merits of the constitutional question are outside the scope of this text. The case is used here because it makes visible a choice that every organization faces when one of its decisions is struck down, and that is rarely governed as a decision.
In the five-stage model used in this series, the ruling is a **Reaction** for the original decision maker. The court's reasons supply much of the **Explanation**. The options for responding form the **Search**. Choosing among them is the **Decision**, and the period that follows is **Action**.
**2. Not contesting is not the same as conceding the goal**
A decision not to appeal can be read in two ways. It can mean the authority accepts the finding and no longer pursues the goal. It can also mean the authority accepts the finding and pursues the same goal, or a modified one, by a different route. The observable trace is the same in both cases: no appeal is filed. The decision behind the trace is different.
This matters because parties outside the authority infer the decision from the trace. Those who opposed the original decision read non-appeal as a win. Those who supported it read it as abandonment. The authority's actual position may be neither. In the Canadian case, the stated plan was to amend the Act and coordinate the amendment with a separate bill. That is a choice of route, not necessarily of goal, although critics argued it would also change the goal.
**Governance answer.** Separate two questions in the record: what the authority intends to achieve after the ruling, and by what route. A decision on route without a statement of goal leaves the goal to be inferred by others, usually by those with the strongest interest in a particular reading.
**3. The choice has more than two options**
Responses to an adverse ruling are usually discussed as appeal or no appeal. In practice the options are wider. An authority can appeal in full. It can appeal a narrow point to obtain clarification while redesigning the rest. It can accept the finding and redesign. It can accept the finding and defer redesign, relying on the fact that the rule remains formally in force. It can seek a negotiated settlement with the party that challenged it. Each option distributes cost, delay, and uncertainty differently among the authority, those who must comply, and those the rule was meant to protect.
**Governance answer.** Require the Search stage to list at least the full appeal, the narrow appeal, redesign, and deferral, with a short assessment of each before a choice is made. The list itself does not determine the answer. It prevents the framing of the decision from excluding options before they are considered.
**4. Criteria for contesting**
The criteria an authority applies to this choice are rarely written down in advance. The following are the ones that most often apply.
- **Probability of success.** The likelihood that a higher body would reverse the finding, given its reasons and any dissent. - **Value of the precedent.** What the authority gains or loses for its other decisions if the finding stands or is reversed. A finding that limits authority across many decisions weighs more than one specific to a single case. - **Time.** How long a contest would take, and what happens to affected parties while it runs. - **Uncertainty for affected parties.** Whether contesting or accepting leaves those who must comply with a clearer rule sooner. - **Consistency with current direction.** Whether the original decision still reflects what the authority wants. Priorities may have changed since it was made. - **Cost of the contest.** Direct legal and staff costs, and the attention of senior decision makers.
The weight of each criterion depends on who is deciding and what they are accountable for. An authority accountable mainly for certainty to investors will weigh time and uncertainty more heavily. An authority accountable mainly for protecting a resource will weigh the value of the precedent more heavily. Neither weighting is correct in general.
**Governance answer.** Adopt the criteria before a ruling arrives, and state which criteria were decisive when the choice is made. A choice explained against stated criteria can be evaluated later. A choice explained only by its outcome cannot.
**5. Escalation of commitment and the authors of the original decision**
Staw (1976) showed that people who are personally responsible for an earlier decision commit more resources to it after negative feedback than people who are not. An adverse ruling is negative feedback. The officials, executives, or advisers who designed the original decision have the most knowledge of it and the strongest reasons to defend it. Their knowledge is needed. Their incentive is a bias.
Escalation is not the only bias that applies. An authority can also abandon a defensible decision too quickly, because a new leadership team has no stake in it or because a ruling offers a convenient exit from a commitment it no longer wants. Both are failures to decide on the criteria.
**Governance answer.** Assign the recommendation on whether to contest to people who did not design the original decision, while requiring the original designers to provide their assessment to them. In a company, this can be a board committee or general counsel working with outside counsel who did not advise on the original decision. In a public body, it can be a law officer or a unit separate from the policy team. The cost is duplication of effort and some loss of the original team's knowledge, and the risk that the separate reviewers underestimate the original decision's merits.
**6. The interval between the old rule and the new one**
Accepting a ruling and redesigning creates an interval. The old rule is formally in force but its validity is in doubt. The new rule does not exist yet. Parties who must comply cannot rely fully on either. The interval is often the largest source of the uncertainty that the decision not to contest was meant to reduce.
In the Canadian case, the interim arrangement was that the assessment agency would continue to work with proponents. That is an arrangement for continuity. Its specific terms, such as which standards apply to projects already in review, were not stated in the announcement.
**Governance answer.** Treat the interval as a decision with its own scope and end date. The authority can state which parts of the old rule it will continue to apply, which it will suspend, how cases already in progress will be handled, and when the new rule is expected. The cost is that interim rules can be challenged in turn, and that a stated date creates a commitment the authority may not be able to keep.
**7. Reasons as part of the decision**
A choice not to contest is often announced with little explanation. Sometimes this is deliberate: stating that a contest was unlikely to succeed can weaken the authority's position in related cases. Sometimes it reflects the fact that the choice was made quickly. In either case, the absence of reasons leaves the choice to be explained by others. Each party supplies the reason that suits its interests.
Procedural justice research finds that people's acceptance of a decision depends substantially on their perception of the process by which it was made, and not only on the outcome (Lind & Tyler, 1988). An unexplained choice not to contest gives affected parties little basis for judging the process.
**Governance answer.** Record the reasons internally in full, against the criteria, and publish the reasons that can be published without prejudicing related matters. Where reasons are withheld, say that they are withheld and why. The cost is the time to prepare the record and the legal risk of what it contains, which can be managed by privilege where it applies.
**8. What the choice signals beyond the case**
A decision not to contest affects more than the rule in question. It tells other parties how the authority responds to challenge. If the authority rarely contests, challengers learn that a finding at a lower level is likely to be final. If it always contests, they learn that any challenge will be long and expensive. Both patterns change the incentives of future challengers and of those who must comply.
**Governance answer.** Review contest decisions as a set, not only one at a time. An annual review of which findings were contested, which were accepted, and on what criteria shows whether the authority's pattern matches its stated approach. The cost is the effort of the review and the possibility that it reveals inconsistency the authority would prefer not to document.
**9. What governing this choice costs**
Governing the response to adverse rulings slows the response. Listing options, separating reviewers from designers, writing reasons, and defining interim rules all take time, and appeal periods are fixed. Pre-set criteria can also constrain an authority that needs to respond to political or market conditions not anticipated when the criteria were written. For an authority that faces few rulings, the overhead may exceed the benefit. For one that faces many, or whose rulings affect many parties, the overhead buys predictability for those parties and a record the authority can learn from.
Decision governance is neutral on whether an authority should contest more or less. The same choice not to appeal can serve one set of parties and harm another. Governance makes the choice explicit, so that it is decided against criteria rather than by inertia, by the original designers' commitment, or by the convenience of the moment.
**References**
- Blakes. (2026, October 26). *Alberta Court of Appeal finds Impact Assessment Act is unconstitutional, again*. [https://www.blakes.com/insights/alberta-court-of-appeal-finds-impact-assessment-act-is-unconstitutional-again/](https://www.blakes.com/insights/alberta-court-of-appeal-finds-impact-assessment-act-is-unconstitutional-again/) - Ecojustice. (2026). *Government's decision not to appeal the Impact Assessment ruling creates uncertainty for environmental protection*. [https://ecojustice.ca/news/federal-governments-decision-not-to-appeal-the-impact-assessment-ruling-creates-uncertainty-for-environmental-protection/](https://ecojustice.ca/news/federal-governments-decision-not-to-appeal-the-impact-assessment-ruling-creates-uncertainty-for-environmental-protection/) - Lind, E. A., & Tyler, T. R. (1988). *The social psychology of procedural justice*. Plenum Press. - Murray, N. (2026, November 12). Feds won't appeal Alberta court ruling that Impact Assessment Act is unconstitutional. *The Canadian Press*, via CKOM. [https://www.ckom.com/2026/11/12/feds-wont-appeal-alberta-court-ruling-that-impact-assessment-act-is-unconstitutional/](https://www.ckom.com/2026/11/12/feds-wont-appeal-alberta-court-ruling-that-impact-assessment-act-is-unconstitutional/) - *Reference re Impact Assessment Act*, 2023 SCC 23. [https://scc-csc.ca/judgments-jugements/cb/2023/40195/](https://scc-csc.ca/judgments-jugements/cb/2023/40195/) - Staw, B. M. (1976). Knee-deep in the big muddy: A study of escalating commitment to a chosen course of action. *Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 16*(1), 27–44. - The Energy Mix. (2026, November 13). *Feds won't appeal Alberta court ruling that Impact Assessment Act is unconstitutional*. [https://www.theenergymix.com/feds-wont-appeal-alberta-court-ruling-that-impact-assessment-act-is-unconstitutional/](https://www.theenergymix.com/feds-wont-appeal-alberta-court-ruling-that-impact-assessment-act-is-unconstitutional/)
**Definitions**
- **Adverse ruling:** A finding by a court, tribunal, or regulator that a decision, or the rule on which it rests, is invalid in whole or in part. - **Contest decision:** The decision by the original decision maker on how to respond to an adverse ruling, including whether to appeal. - **Observable trace:** What outsiders can see of a decision, such as an appeal filed or not filed, as distinct from the decision and reasons behind it. - **Escalation of commitment:** The tendency of those responsible for an earlier decision to commit further resources to it after negative feedback (Staw, 1976). - **Interval rules:** The rules an authority applies between accepting an adverse ruling and putting a replacement in place. - **Reference:** In Canadian law, a question referred by a government to a court for an advisory opinion, rather than a dispute between parties.